Welcome to Di Fara Pizza
Di Fara Pizza, located in Brooklyn's Midwood neighborhood, is renowned for its authentic old-school New York pizza. Reviewers raved about the perfectly crispy crust, generous toppings, and unique touches like ripped basil. Customers praised the balance of cheese, sauce, and dough, with some calling it the best slice they've ever had. The small, bustling shop may have limited seating, but the flavorful pizzas make it a must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts. With loyal patrons willing to make long journeys for a taste of their pies, Di Fara Pizza truly stands out as a slice of pizza paradise in New York City.
-
1424 Ave J Brooklyn, NY 11230 Hotline: (718) 258-1367
Welcome to Di Fara Pizza, where pizza perfection is not just a promise, but a reality. Located in the bustling Midwood neighborhood of Brooklyn, this unassuming gem has been drawing pizza enthusiasts from far and wide to savor its delectable offerings.
Step inside and you'll be greeted by the sight and aroma of expertly crafted pies, each one a testament to the artistry and dedication of the pizzaiolos behind the counter. Whether you opt for a classic round slice or a square grandma slice, you can expect a pizza experience like no other.
What sets Di Fara apart from the rest is its commitment to using the freshest ingredients, from the tangy tomato sauce to the gooey mozzarella cheese. The thin, crispy crust provides the perfect canvas for each flavorful topping, creating a symphony of taste in every bite.
But what truly elevates Di Fara to legendary status is its attention to detail. The addition of ripped basil leaves adds a subtle yet distinct flavor profile, while the precise balance of cheese, sauce, and dough ensures that every slice is a culinary masterpiece.
Don't just take our word for it - heed the glowing reviews from loyal customers who have made the pilgrimage to Di Fara time and time again. From the impeccable crust to the saucy goodness, each visit is a testament to pizza perfection.
So, if you find yourself craving a slice of heaven in the heart of Brooklyn, look no further than Di Fara Pizza. Prepare to be transported to pizza nirvana with every bite.
Yes, I'll admit it. I trust Dave Portnoy's pizza reviews - it's to the point where when I conduct business travel, I'll only stop at places he rates at an 8 or higher. Am I becoming a pizza snob in my old age? Probably. I don't care. I told someone that I've lived in various cities in CA most of my life, and tried plenty of pies there. Taking chains out of the equation (which are mostly inedible), I believe some of the worst NY pizza (which includes New Haven, CT) would rank amongst the best in California. My continued pilgrimage to experience pizza excellence this particular trip brought me to Johnny's in Mt. Vernon and Di Fara deep in Brooklyn (Midwood neighborhood). I tried two slices - one regular and one square. The square one (maybe a grandma slice?) featured a thicker crust with more "heft", while the thinner crust had an extra crunchy crust. Zero flop on both. Pristine undercarriage. This place is a bit unique in that it features pieces of ripped basil, which adds a certain subtle boost of flavor. I'm normally a pepperoni or sausage guy. However, I wanted to have this one naked - no toppings, just cheese. This is the only true test of a pizza's base level of quality. Let me state unequivocally. Johnny's was extremely tasty, but Di Fara was on another level of unf---king-believableness. Nirvana. Manna from heaven. Pure bliss. All of it. You need to come here. You should be ashamed of yourself, because you SHOULD'VE been here already. Dave gave this a 9.4 - I'm throwing down a 9.8. Enjoy.
The wait time was worth it for the pizza. The service was average but WOW was the pizza amazing. Highly recommended. Eat here
Just damn good NY pizza. Can't ask for anything more. You want authentic old school NY pizza, made with fresh ingredients and you are in South BK, make your way here.
I've been to Di Fara so many times, so I feel it's important to post about it. The last time I went is when Dom (RIP) was grabbing pies out with his bare hands. Everytime I went there was over a hour wait but I did not care. I lived in Williamsburg so the train ride took forever but I did not care. Absolutely the best pizza I've had in my life. Anytime that I'm in NYC, I make the trek down to Ave J for a slice.
Absolutely lived up to the hype. Every accolade is well deserved. Easily one of the best, if not the best slice I have ever had. Amazing crisp crust that stands straight out at attention without being too tough. Incredible snap when you bite into it. Great crust around the edge. You can hear how awesome it is from across the table. The sauce and cheese are delicious and in the proper proportion. Very fun old-school vibe. Just a great outing. Cannot wait to go back. I don't care how long the subway ride is.
Now THIS is what you call a good slice. I always see Di Fara come up when talking best slices in NYC and it did not disappoint. The place looks like it's been there forever, which is pretty much has lol. We were waiting for a plain slice but it was still in the over so we got two pepperoni slices for the same price (who am I to complain about free pepperoni?!). The slice was perfect, the dough was SO SO good, the pepperoni delicious. They sprinkle what looks like pecorino Romano and fresh basil on the pizza. 10/10. Definitely one of the best in NYC and worth the trip.
This is about as good as pizza is gona get. Thin and crispy, get a crunch with each bite. The ratio of cheese, sauce and dough are perfectly balance like a pizza should be. The crust has even more crunch. The flavor of the sauce is so amazing, a slightly sweet and good tang to it. I love when pizza spots put 2 cheeses, mozzarella and parmesan together. Gives it so much more flavor. And to finish it off you get shredded basil. I got the cheese and my friend got pepperoni. He loved his as well. The shop is small, not really much room to eat inside so we ate outside which was cool with me. Nice area. Friendly staff. Busy because it's so popular. An absolute must try when you come to New York.
Really interesting pizza! Very saucy. Super crunchy crust. Maybe the crunchiest crust I've ever had. $5 for a slice which is a bit steep compared to some other places. Would recommend, but definitely different than what I expected! Some tables to sit at inside. Nice lady working at the front.